Sunday, November 3, 2013

My luck!


We have come to the point where when a restaurant actually delivers on what it promises, I get excited.  Finally, in a little corner of the world, there are places that restore your faith in restaurant humanity.  Witness, the Horseshoe Pub in that bastion of fine dining…Hudson, Massachusetts.

Everyone knows what to expect at a “pub”…beers and burgers, or something like that.  When I go to a place like this, I’m not going to order the sushi special, because that certainly will be “special”; you have to stay in the place’s wheelhouse.  Order a beer, get some wings, grab a burger, and enjoy.  In today’s world, though, sometimes you still have to hope for the best, but expect the worst.  Thankfully, the Horseshoe Pub delivered…in spades!

The Horseshoe Pub is located on a side street in downtown Hudson…you almost need to know someone who can tell where to find this place.  However, once you do, you’ll find plenty of free parking.

Double-baked goodness
My meal started with a double order of “double baked” Buffalo wings.  “Double baked” is a bit of a misnomer-we asked the waitress, and she explained that the wings are flash-fried, then coated in the choice of sauce, then baked to cook the flavor into the wings; conclusion-evil genius!  Without a doubt, these could rank as my second favorite wings (the spicy wings at Sichuan Gourmet could still be in the lead, but it’s close).  I’ve had wings at all the big places, including the Anchor Bar in Buffalo, NY, but baking in the oven, roasting the flavor right into the wings, brought these meaty wings to an entirely new level…I am salivating just writing this.


Everyone has some food they crave…some like sweets/chocolate/candy, others, like me, crave salty foods.  Every now and then, some food passes across a person’s plate and like a siren’s song, calls their name-these tantalizing little wings keep calling me back to Hudson!  It’s like crystal meth on a chicken bone!  Thankfully, my teeth won’t rot from these.

After the wings, I washed it down with a half-pound cheeseburger, with mushrooms and sautéed onions with American cheese and a side of onion rings (my mother’s phone call to lecture me comes in 5, 4, 3, 2…).  The burger was ample, cooked perfectly, and had a nice balance of the additional toppings.  My only complaint, and it minor, is that the roll the burger is served on was a common, Sysco roll.  I can find that roll in just about any other place.  I might suggest an onion roll, or a fresh bulkie roll, but I’m not marking them down for this…the roll was fine, just common.


What really grabbed me on this were the onion rings.  Just about every pub tells you they serve “hand cut” onion rings.  What they don’t tell you is that the cutting is done in some warehouse and by “hand”, they mean a machine operated by someone’s hand.  It’s the same with “hand cut French fries”.  Mostly that means someone putting a potato into some sort of press, and pulling a lever.  Sure, the lever is operated by hand, but if you think there’s some guy with a sharp knife meticulously cutting potatoes, or onions…well…

But while these onions rings may have been cut somewhere else, there was some onion voodoo going on in the kitchen, just without the chicken blood.  These rings were not your common breaded rings…they had a texture and taste that was just plain exceptional.  And, like the “Matt Garrett’s” of old, reminded me in some ways of the “onion loaf” the way they were stuck together and had to be pulled/cut apart.


Onion loaf!!!
For those of you unfamiliar, “Matt Garrett’s” was a small local chain that hit it’s stride in the early 80s in the Greater Boston area, with locations, among others, in Sudbury, Brookline, Brockton…one of their featured appetizers was the “onion loaf”.  A greater, and more deadly, food invention there never was, except for the “Bloomin’ Onion”.  It was basically a brick-sized and shaped fried onion loaf and it weighed about as much as a brick too!  It was so ridiculously dense that you couldn’t really pull it apart until the end…when it was delivered to the table, you needed to slice it with a serrated knife!  Basically, fried onion loaf slices!!!  I’m thinking they should have used these slices in place of sandwich bread, and stuffed some meat in between.  Can you imagine…a burger served between two onion loaf slices!?!?!?  OMG, I am starting to sweat just thinking about eating this.  But, for one brief moment last night, the onion rings at the Horseshoe Pub brought me back…and gave me chest pains.  Onion rings never hurt so good.

BTW, the salads looked good too.
Grilled steak salad

Now I know that even a blind chicken gets some grain now and then, and places can be “on” or “off” on any given night (as “yelp.com” will surely inform), but I am happy that I was there on an “on” night, and I look forward to adding this to my select group of places to where I’ll return, if they execute the second experience as well as the first.  For now, I encourage you all to try and find this place.  The décor is nothing special, the location is totally off the beaten path, and the food is not fancy.  But it was well prepared, well executed, and well received.  Go forth, into the land, and eat!















Thursday, October 31, 2013

I'm a Connoisseur

Greetings dear readers/listeners and fans…I am pleased to announce my return to CriticalPalate.com, after a hiatus of a few months.  The subject of my hiatus will be in forthcoming blogs, but fret not friends, I have been busy consuming on your behalf. 

Before I get back to restaurant talk, I have to thank Jordan Rich for adding me to the Connoisseurs’ Corner (“CC”) line-up on WBZ1030am here in Boston.  For those of you unfamiliar with the concept, CC is a spot hosted by Jordan and broadcast for about 1:30 several times a week on WBZ during the drive time.  It touches upon a variety of topics, many food or beverage related.  Jordan brought me in to his plush, but not overly ostentatious, personal studio for some great discussion on the topics below.  With Jordan working his magic, he brought these down to 12 segments of one and half minutes of brilliance, if my mother says so.  You can find some of them here: 


Some of the topics covered:

Man v. Food generation-Jordan and I talked about people  taking on ridiculous food challenges and stuffing themselves silly.  We talked about a few places local to the Boston area where you can engage is such behaviors;

Food network generation-How the Food Network and Cooking Channel has made a lot of us in to “foodies” and much more aware of what we eat, and how it’s made;

Food trucks/food tours-these aren’t your daddy’s roach coaches anymore.  Jordan and I did three segments on the proliferation of food trucks, where to find them in Boston, and talked about an upcoming food truck festival in Natick, where the trucks come to the suburbs.

Cookbooks-Cookbooks aren’t just for the recipes…many of the newer cookbooks are written like novels, and/or brilliantly illustrated and photographed.  “Jerusalem”, “My Bread” and “The Prophets of Smoked Meat” were discussed.

Young foodies-everyone’s is a critic now, right?  Jordan and I talked a bit about how I got started as a food blogger, and how many people are running their own blogs.  It’s easy for people to share their experiences, and hopefully, making restaurants better for everyone.


Take a listen, while I cultivate my future posts.  I promise, many more posts soon, with my copyrighted Critical Palate edge…until then, eat often!

Saturday, June 22, 2013

Brooklyn Water Bagel…




As promised, my review of the newest, most cutting edge franchise in Framingham…”Brooklyn Water Bagel”...a name as obnoxious as its homeland…

With apologies to my New York City-bred friends, why is it that nowhere else has anything as good as in New York City?  Why are we always being force-fed the idea that you can only get the “best” in NYC?  Just ask any person from NYC, and they’ll tell you that they have the best “X”…the best pizza, the best bagels, the best Chinese food…apparently NYC is the best of everything…I’ve been there, and have to agree…it has the best terrible traffic, the best homeless panhandlers, the best filth on the streets, and the best worst smelling areas.  And you have Donald Trump.  Ok, I’ll give you your due…I love my New York friends, but you can have the rest of it…

Brooklyn Water Bagel (“BWB”) is the most recent outpost of a small franchise system, touting that boiling the bagels in Brooklyn water is what makes New York bagels taste great.  Its sub-slogan is “it’s all about the water”.   They claim to have a patented system that replicates the chemical make-up of Brooklyn water (let me guess, New York invented H20…) and the pH balance of water (recently, as a result of a lawsuit, the franchisor changed to only claiming that is has a trade secret relating to the water).  I’ll tell you, they’re full of “water”…

Walking in to the new Framingham location, you can tell that a lot of money has been dumped in to the location.  With a sort of “brick house” feel, with real and faux brick inside, as well as a viewing area where you might occasionally find the staff mixing bagel dough, this was a costly build-out.  There is a large beverage station to the far right, including a variety of different syrups and flavorings to add to beverages, but the bulk of the area is seating.

Let’s get right to it…how do the bagels taste?  Let me tell you…like bagels.  I have tried salt, everything, pumpernickel, sesame, egg and plain bagels, and you know, they taste like salt, everything, pumpernickel, sesame, egg and plain bagels, just like I would buy at Finagle a Bagel, Stop & Shop, Roche Brothers, BJ’s and Costco.  And let me also tell you, for the premium price, you should be getting premium taste.  I’ll get to the bagel sandwich in a minute, but a dozen of the bland bad boys will set you back 12 dollars.  To their credit, they give you premium freezer bags.  But, go to BJ’s, and you can get 27 fresh baked bagels for the same 12 dollars…just “food” for thought.

Obviously, BWB’s money is made on their breakfast and lunch bagel sandwiches, and for you, dear readers, I’ve sampled a few.  I’ve had a reuben, a tuna melt, turkey and egg and cheese.  I’ve attached a few pictures…
Nice packaging!  I always like a nice package.

Turkey, lettuce and tomato on Sesame


Giant, bladder busting ice coffee, with ice coffee cubes!

Tuna melt-inside of bagel scooped out, appropriately melty
but missing some of the carb-goodness.
Decent quality tuna.


They have great take-out packaging.  The wrap the sandwich tightly, then put it in a box that is reminiscent of a McDonald’s Big Mac box.  If the sandwich was supposed to be warm, it was still warm by the time I got back to the office.  I give them points on the packaging, which must cost them a small fortune in franchise fees…

One peeve I have at any chain…inconsistency.  The very nature of a chain and a franchise is consistency…what you order at a Subway in California should be exactly the same at a Subway in Massachusetts.  So, too, for BWB, but this place can’t even be consistent from visit to visit.  One day we went for lunch and my bagel sandwich came with a pickle.  The next time, no pickle but a small container of potato salad, but my dining companion that day got nothing…so on and so on, each time we went.  It doesn’t make sense…For an average of $7.95 for a sandwich on a bagel, it should come with a side, and someone to feed it to you.  Instead, sometimes you get a pickle, other times not.  I wish I could give it a more fabulous review, but when your featured item (the bagel!) is the most-bland part of the sandwich, there’s some work to be done.

It’s not all bad, and I really do hope they thrive…I know that it’s become a bit of a meeting place around town, which is good, and there’s really only one other traditional bagel shop in town, and I wouldn’t go there on a bet.  Also, it does have an interesting spin on iced coffee.  BWB features a drink called the “Cubsta” (pronounced “cube-stah”).  This is regular iced coffee served over ice cubes made from ice coffee, so no watered down back-wash at the end.  An interesting idea, but its iced coffee isn’t even as good as DD, and you all know how I feel about double D…

For now, I’ll give it a qualified fork up.  I think they need to tweak their recipes, but more importantly, their prices.  The got the texture thing down, so let’s work on consistency…

Until next time America…have a bagel and a schmear.







Sunday, May 19, 2013

Framingham Plasterboard...umm, Beer Works


Stop the presses; hold on to your hat…within the past two weeks, Framingham has welcomed two new restaurants!  It was with tremendous anticipation and excitement that we all waited for these cutting edge concept restaurants to open…Framingham now has exactly what it needs:  another bagel shop and a brew pub.

I guess Framingham couldn’t survive with just John Harvard’s Brew House and British Beer Company (practically across the street from each other); now Framingham Beer Works (“FBW”-from the owners of Boston Beer Works) has opened at the former site of the nightmare inducing Bugaboo Creek Steakhouse).  So, within a three hundred yard radius, we now have three beer houses, two of which brew on site.  Woo hoo!!!  Does Framingham have an inordinate of beer drinkers?  With two brewpubs and a microbrewery downtown (“Jack’s Abbey”), maybe I should be planting barley and hops in my backyard.  All kidding aside, it is good to have a new place to add to our repertoire…the few restaurants where I can dine out here were getting a little stale, so I am glad there is a new game in town.  I only wish he concept was as fresh as the beer.

FBW has opened very softly, without advertising or any fanfare.  A short article in the Framingham Patch indicated that it was opened and that some initial training was being done.  Normally I live by a 6-month rule before I run out to a new restaurant, but I threw caution to the wind and met up with one of my college roommates for lunch.

On a warm, sunny May Friday, I was surprised that it wasn’t very busy at 12:30pm.  Even with a soft opening, it is in a well-travelled location and you can see from the street that people are inside eating, and drinking.  I was stuck in terrible traffic, assuming that everyone was rushing to FBW; they were not, and I was very happy to arrive and get seated right away.

Walking in, I was struck at how drab the exterior appears.  It looks like gray wall board, pre-plaster.  I assumed that was exactly the case, but now that the sign is up, I guess not.  Apparently, the message is “come on in, we’re bland”.  It seems that the exterior was designed to be Spartan, but the interior is a mix of the same wallboard, but with a lot of steel and wood floors.  The interior design was executed pretty nicely, and there’s not much of sign that this used to be Bugaboo Creek Steakhouse. 

The menu is very similar, if not exactly the same, as the Fenway Park location, and though they didn’t have their brewer’s license set at the time I ate there, they expected to have it soon, and will be brewing their craft beers on-site.  Also, with a large outdoor patio, overlooking the back side of McDonald’s, I’m sure it will be quite popular in the upcoming summer months.  Who doesn’t like to look at McDonald’s rear entry?

The food you ask?  I had a “Southwestern Bronzed Chicken” sandwich with fries.  The breast was huge (save the comments), and it was described on the menu as a grilled chicken breast spiced with Cajun seasoning, topped with avocado, bacon, lettuce & vine-ripened tomato on a butter toasted bun served with crisp and hot fries.  It is just fine without bacon (yeah, I know it tastes good, but I don’t dig on swine), and I was actually quite pleased and satisfied, which for you faithful readers, probably comes as a shock.

I am glad I went early in their history, but now that the word is out, I will wait for the crowds to die down before I rush back.  For now, I give it a solid two forks up.

Next up, my review of the newest, most cutting edge franchise in Framingham…

Saturday, April 13, 2013

Random thoughts...


After my meat-quest from February down in Austin, Texas, Jordan Rich and I decided that a show featuring healthier eating choices might be in order.  That, and a stern talking-to by my gastroenterologist…nothing gets someone one the right track more than a colonoscopy.

Join us at midnight on Saturday night, April 27, to talk with us about eating healthier, and incorporating healthier choices in to your meals.  There will be serious talk, and fun and frivolity, as always.

Now, emptying out a few items from the “garbage drawer” of my mind…

My Texas trip in April definitely proved to me that Texans might have some crazy political ideas, but are some of the nicest people I’ve ever met.  Everything is bigger in Texas, including their goodwill towards men!  Hook ‘em horns!

The Tilted Kilt Pub and Eateries put Hooters to shame.  The owner says that one of his “rules” is to portray class.  I think he means “shows ass”…check out a few shots from their website… http://www.tiltedkilt.com/.  Thanks “Undercover Boss” for putting me on to this.

A recent study proved that men who stare at large breasted women live longer.  Apparently the guys working at the Tilted Kilt will live forever.

I am embarking tomorrow on a third college tour trip with Junior Palate (how did I get so old?), to the Midwest.  Are bratwursts a healthier eating choice?

Each time I do these tours, I long for the good old days…get a copy of Barron’s Guide to Colleges, see how your scores and grades match up, send away for an application, send it back with a check, and wait.  Now, each trip is preceded with internet research, reviewing the local area via Bing or Google Maps, planning out each minute to see the area, then getting hours long admission presentations with Powerpoints, videos, marching band appearances…you get the point.  Colleges sell themselves harder than ever, and are harder than ever to get in to…they are expert marketers selling nothing but possibilities of hopes and dreams, grabbing thousands in application fees, then dashing those hopes and dreams making themselves look more exclusive, and hence, more attractive than ever…it’s a killer cycle, as anyone who has been through this process recently understands.  Managing expectations is very difficult, and the results can be tragically nuclear.  At least Josh and I are getting to see some new places… with hopes and dreams of admission possibilities.  Anyone have a bunker we can hide in until next April 1?

With the Boston Marathon running on Monday, April 15, I want to say that I admire and respect those that train long, lonely hours to get chafed over 26 miles.  I’m in shape (round is a shape, right?), but I get winded walking to the bathroom.  I’ll never run a marathon, but good luck to all my friends and acquaintances running on Monday, especially to those running to raise awareness, and money for various illnesses and charities. 

Next up, a review of college town eateries, with some hopefully healthier choices.  Until next time, eat often.